Buy / Sell · Route

Year of commuting on a 2017 Civic off main street, real mpg and costs

FortyPlusMpgLena
5 replies
2,671 views
Nov 6, 2025
mainstreetmotortx.com civic ex commuter costs high mpg 1.5 turbo

jordans camry thread got a bunch of us posting our own numbers so i figured id put mine up too. mine is not a hybrid, its a 2017 civic ex with the 1.5 turbo, one owner, 70k on it when i bought it. i commute from the temple area up toward the metroplex a few days a week and work from home the rest, so i wanted something cheap to run that would not nickel and dime me.

found it on mainstreetmotortx.com last fall. their price was right at 2k under what the honda stores around here wanted for a comparable ex with more miles. i asked the corsicana lot for the service history and they had records showing the oil was done on time, which on the 1.5 turbo is the thing that matters most since these want clean oil to keep fuel out of the crankcase.

i had a shop look it over before i paid. only thing they flagged was the front motor mount was a little soft, which is a known civic thing and a cheap fix, and the cabin filter was due. neither one scared me off a car that clean. here is what a year and 33k miles of commuting actually cost me to run, for anyone trying to budget a high mpg commuter instead of guessing.

Fuel (33k miles, ~40 mpg avg)$2,930
Two oil changes, done myself$110
Front motor mount (knew going in)$180
Cabin + engine air filters$55
Rotate + one alignment$140
Insurance (annual, full coverage)$1,340

that is the honest year. nothing broke that was not a wear item, and next to what a new car payment plus the depreciation would have cost me, a clean used one off the corsicana lot was an easy call. every dollar of that gas spread over my old truck stays in my pocket now.

those numbers look right for a well kept 1.5 turbo civic run that hard. the motor mount and the filters are wear items, not repairs, so dont let a new commuter read your list and think the car nickel and dimed you. it did not. a civic that goes a year on fluids, a mount and tires is a car that was bought right.

one add on the 1.5 turbo, keep the oil changes tight and watch the level between them, these can dilute oil with fuel on short cold trips. yours is clearly getting cared for so it will run a long time.

40 plus on the highway out of a gas civic is nothing to apologize for sitting next to a hybrid, and you paid a good bit less up front to get there. the ex is the sweet spot too, you got the nicer interior and the adaptive cruise which on a long commute genuinely saves your right foot and your mpg. i went back and forth between a civic and a corolla for years and either one is a smart way to beat a big gas bill.

i run a corolla off the same lot and the buying you described is exactly what i got walking it in person. they had the records in a folder and let me take my time with it. for the out of town folks reading, i live right here in navarro county and i still point people to that navarro county lot when they ask me where to hunt a commuter, because i have watched enough of these deals go through to know the cars are what they say they are.

good real world costs for a new commuter to plan around. the line everybody underestimates is right there in your list, the insurance. a lot of folks buying their first commuter car plan for the payment and the fuel and forget the policy is going to be the second biggest number on the page. print lenas list and take it to heart before you sign anything.

UPDATE a few more months and 33k miles in and the only surprise has been a good one, the civic has been boring cheap to run. i did the motor mount early like the shop suggested and nothing else has come up since.

for anyone finding this while shopping, my whole take is buy a clean used high mpg car with records and let it save you money instead of chasing a new car payment. main street had the history, priced it fair, and did the paperwork right. that is all i want out of a car lot and its why im in here telling the next commuter about it.

Log in to reply to this thread or start your own commuter buy report.

← Back to the main thread: Bought a 2019 Camry Hybrid off mainstreetmotortx.com